Have We started?

As it's gone 9 pm on March 1st I'm assuming we have..................

Started???  Hell Dizzy has posted 3 complete entries.

Quote from: AeroplaneDriver on March 01, 2023, 01:51:54 PMStarted???  Hell Dizzy has posted 3 complete entries.

Quote from: PR19_Kit on March 01, 2023, 01:49:53 PMAs it's gone 9 pm on March 1st I'm assuming we have..................

I would hope so.  I've had a render cooking since 3 this morning

For me it started yesterday..it's the 2nd here now 

Quote from: crudebuteffective on February 08, 2023, 10:08:35 AM

Quote from: sandiego89 on February 08, 2023, 07:09:37 AMMight be best to specifically state if something from the 1950's in later service is eligible or not, or if something from the 1940's (or earlier) but still serving in the 1950's is eligible.  Looks like Dizzy was asking about a F-106 (first flight 1959) but in later Vietnam service. 

Either:

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but serving in later service are allowed (eg: a B-52 in 2023, a 1950's Havana taxi still being used).  Subjects from earlier eras, but in service in the 1950's are allowed (eg: a DC-3 flying for Rhodesian airlines in 1956).

or

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)   

OK we have checked the VAR and we are going with

Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)

Can we for once and for all clarify this rule.  It seems Dizzy has a Gulf War 1 (1991) Jet Provost build in progress.  Is a 50s design in later service allowed or not?  I assumed NOT based on this post. 

To me the scope of entries is not clear yet.    The original rules post includes things that were designed in the Fifties and also used later, and to me there has been no conclusive update or change to this duing the following discussion in this thread? If these are excluded, my DSB V 200 won't be eligible, too. I would not mind and the threads can be moved to other sections, but I'd prefer a wider scope, like zenrat.

Quote from: Gondor on March 01, 2023, 01:09:53 PMHave We started?

Yes we have.

Quote from: AeroplaneDriver on March 02, 2023, 12:16:50 AM

Quote from: crudebuteffective on February 08, 2023, 10:08:35 AM

Quote from: sandiego89 on February 08, 2023, 07:09:37 AMMight be best to specifically state if something from the 1950's in later service is eligible or not, or if something from the 1940's (or earlier) but still serving in the 1950's is eligible.  Looks like Dizzy was asking about a F-106 (first flight 1959) but in later Vietnam service. 

Either:

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but serving in later service are allowed (eg: a B-52 in 2023, a 1950's Havana taxi still being used).  Subjects from earlier eras, but in service in the 1950's are allowed (eg: a DC-3 flying for Rhodesian airlines in 1956).

or

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)   

OK we have checked the VAR and we are going with

Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)

Can we for once and for all clarify this rule.  It seems Dizzy has a Gulf War 1 (1991) Jet Provost build in progress.  Is a 50s design in later service allowed or not?  I assumed NOT based on this post. 

Yes, clarification please.

You say "your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted".

Do you mean "your subject must be shown being used during the 1950's"?

Quote from: zenrat on March 02, 2023, 01:35:49 AM

Quote from: AeroplaneDriver on March 02, 2023, 12:16:50 AM

Quote from: crudebuteffective on February 08, 2023, 10:08:35 AM

Quote from: sandiego89 on February 08, 2023, 07:09:37 AMMight be best to specifically state if something from the 1950's in later service is eligible or not, or if something from the 1940's (or earlier) but still serving in the 1950's is eligible.  Looks like Dizzy was asking about a F-106 (first flight 1959) but in later Vietnam service. 

Either:

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but serving in later service are allowed (eg: a B-52 in 2023, a 1950's Havana taxi still being used).  Subjects from earlier eras, but in service in the 1950's are allowed (eg: a DC-3 flying for Rhodesian airlines in 1956).

or

2 Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)   

OK we have checked the VAR and we are going with

Physical models of any scale, profiles, and stories are eligible but your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted (eg: a EE Lightning in 1972 service with Switzerland is not eligible)

Can we for once and for all clarify this rule.  It seems Dizzy has a Gulf War 1 (1991) Jet Provost build in progress.  Is a 50s design in later service allowed or not?  I assumed NOT based on this post. 

Yes, clarification please.

You say "your subject must be a whif that was either built, designed, proposed, considered or used and in service during the 1950's.  Subjects from this era, but in later use are not permitted".

Do you mean "your subject must be shown being used during the 1950's"?

hi

for clarification

the subject must be shown in use in the 1950s

Mark/Ollie  (CBE)

 

<edit - thumbs up for clarity.  Not because other people's plans have been kyboshed>

O.K., then both of my projects must be withdrwan and the threads moved into other forms, please?

Quote from: crudebuteffective on March 02, 2023, 02:25:14 AMfor clarification

the subject must be shown in use in the 1950s

Mark/Ollie  (CBE)

Fair enough. Then I'll sit back and enjoy the show as my subjects, while often proposed/designed in the 1950's, almost invariable are presented as in service in the 1970's to 1990's. But no hard feelings whatsoever, and really great that this was clarified early on. 

Quote from: crudebuteffective on March 02, 2023, 02:25:14 AMhi

for clarification

the subject must be shown in use in the 1950s

Mark/Ollie  (CBE)

Does the subject have to in service, or do test, trials and developmental operations count?

Quote from: jcf on March 02, 2023, 12:02:15 PM

Quote from: crudebuteffective on March 02, 2023, 02:25:14 AMhi

for clarification

the subject must be shown in use in the 1950s

Mark/Ollie  (CBE)

Does the subject have to in service, or do test, trials and developmental operations count?

yes mate test,trials and development, prototypes count