Has anyone else (who will admit to it) ever done this??

[Jennings]

Written a "what-if" model review?  I'll have to admit to actually sitting down at a typewriter (before there were PC's) and writing a review of the Monogram 1/72 KC-135A kit.  It didn't then, and never has existed anywhere outside my mind.  But BOY was it a good kit!!  I think I may have written a review of the 1/48 Hasegawa MiG-25 as well.

I *know* I'm not the only person who's done that, right?   Please say I'm not....

[lenny100]

not actually done it but though about it a few times, might be something we should start

[puddingwrestler]

I wrote a JMN level nit-picking of the faults review of a kid's press out tab-and-slot printed cardboard model plane once.
You can read it here.
Funny thing is some people took it seriously...

[Alvis 3.14159]

Yup. Kinda.
http://www.starshipmodeler.com/other/ap_04012009.htm

It's a model I made up, so why not make up a review too?

Alvis Pi

[Mossie]

I never got around to it, but I nearly wrote a mock review of a Hasegawa Egg Plane (can't remember which, either P-40 or F-5) from the JMN point of view.  I'd seen a few comments on other forums about the Egg Planes being a waste of time & not seeing the point, so my idea was to write it as if I was horrified at the extraordinary innacuarcy.

[PR19_Kit]

Mossie, do it, DO IT!

That's got to be a total hoot. 

[Weaver]

Yup. Kinda.
http://www.starshipmodeler.com/other/ap_04012009.htm

It's a model I made up, so why not make up a review too?

Alvis Pi

Class....

[GTX]

Great idea - we could find a whole new way to stir JMNs with these.

Regards,

Greg